Water Heater Heating Element Replacement: Costs, Options, and Tankless Water Heater Facts
If you’ve already learned how to spot a failing heating element, the next questions usually come fast: How much does a water heater element cost? Can it be replaced? And what happens if I have a tankless water heater instead?
You’re not alone. This guide goes a step further by breaking down costs, explaining your options, and clearing up confusion around tankless water heaters and heating elements.
What Does a Water Heater Heating Element Actually Do?
In an electric water heater, the heating element is the part that warms the water inside the tank. Most standard electric units have two heating elements—an upper and a lower element—working together to maintain consistent hot water. When one element fails, you may still get some hot water, but not enough. When both fail, you’re left with cold water no matter how long you wait. It’s a common issue—and a fixable one.
How Much Does a Water Heater Heating Element Cost?
One of the biggest questions homeowners ask is: How much is an element for a hot water heater?
Here’s what typically goes into the cost:
The heating element itself (varies by wattage and brand)
Labor to diagnose and replace the element
System condition, including age, sediment buildup, and accessibility
In many cases, replacing a heating element is more affordable than replacing the entire water heater—if the tank itself is still in good condition. However, if sediment has damaged the tank or other components are failing, replacement may be the smarter long-term option.
Electric vs. Gas: Do Gas Water Heaters Have Heating Elements?
This is where confusion often sets in. Despite frequent searches for gas water heater element, traditional gas water heaters do not use heating elements.
Instead, gas units rely on:
A burner
A pilot light or electronic ignition
A heat exchanger
If a gas water heater isn’t producing hot water, the issue is usually related to ignition, gas supply, or burner operation—not a heating element. That’s why professional diagnosis matters before assuming the fix.
Do Tankless Water Heaters Have Heating Elements?
Yes — but with an important distinction.
Electric Tankless Water Heaters
Electric tankless systems use multiple electric heating elements that activate only when hot water is needed. These elements can wear out over time, especially in areas with hard water.
Gas Tankless Water Heaters
Gas tankless units do not use traditional heating elements. They heat water using burners and heat exchangers, similar to gas tank water heaters.
So while tankless systems can lose hot water, the cause is usually different—and maintenance plays a much bigger role.
How to Care for Tankless Water Heaters to Prevent Hot Water Loss
Tankless water heaters are efficient, but they’re not maintenance-free. One of the most common reasons homeowners lose hot water with a tankless system is scale buildup.
Hard water minerals collect on internal components, reducing efficiency and stressing heating elements or heat exchangers. Over time, this can cause:
Reduced hot water output
Inconsistent temperatures
Error codes or shutdowns
Annual professional flushing and descaling helps protect the system and extend its lifespan. This simple service can prevent many of the issues that lead homeowners to search “why does my tankless water heater have no hot water?”
When Replacing the Element Makes Sense — and When It Doesn’t
Replacing a heating element is often a smart move when:
The water heater is relatively young
The tank is in good condition
The problem is isolated to the element
However, replacement may not be the best choice if:
The tank is leaking or heavily corroded
Sediment has caused repeated failures
The unit is near the end of its lifespan
In those cases, continuing to replace parts can cost more than upgrading to a new tank or tankless system.
Why Professional Diagnosis Matters
With so many searches focused on how much does a water heater element cost or cost of heating element for hot water heater, it’s tempting to focus only on price. But the real value comes from knowing why the element failed and whether replacement will actually solve the problem.
A professional inspection from Sanders Plumbing HVAC helps ensure you’re not throwing money at a temporary fix.
Hot Water Problems Don’t Have to Be a Guessing Game
Whether you have a traditional electric water heater, a gas system, or a modern tankless unit, understanding how heating elements work—and how to care for them—can save you time, money, and cold showers.
If your hot water isn’t keeping up, the cause may be simpler than you think. And catching it early often makes all the difference.
Frequently Asked Questions: Water Heater Heating Elements + Tankless
-
Heating element prices vary by brand and wattage. The total cost also depends on diagnosis, labor, and whether sediment buildup complicates the repair.
-
Replacement cost depends on access to the unit, whether one or both elements are bad, and the condition of the tank. A professional diagnosis prevents paying for the wrong fix.
-
A failed lower element often means you get some hot water, but it runs out quickly. A failed upper element can lead to little or no hot water at all.
-
Yes—if the tank is in good condition and not leaking. If the tank is old, corroded, or leaking, replacement is usually the better long-term move.
-
Element prices vary, but choosing the correct type (voltage/wattage/length) matters. Buying the wrong element can cause continued hot water problems.
-
Traditional gas tank water heaters heat water with a burner and do not use electric heating elements. If a gas unit has no hot water, the cause is typically ignition, burner, gas supply, or venting—not an “element.”
-
Electric tankless water heaters use heating elements. Gas tankless water heaters heat using burners and a heat exchanger (not electric elements like tank-style electric units).
-
Common causes include scale buildup, dirty inlet screens/filters, flow rate issues, or error conditions. Regular flushing and maintenance helps prevent hot water loss.
-
Many manufacturers recommend regular flushing, often annually, especially in areas with mineral-heavy water. A technician can confirm the right schedule for your system.
-
If the heater is near the end of its lifespan or shows signs of corrosion/leaks, replacement may be more cost-effective than repeated repairs.